If you’re planning a perfect island getaway in Mexico, Central America, or South America, Travel + Leisure’s 2024 readers have spoken—and their favorites are a breathtaking mix of wild adventure, pure relaxation, and unforgettable beauty. This year’s “World’s Best Awards” survey highlights the region’s five most loved islands, each celebrated for its unique vibe, incredible beaches, local food, and welcoming communities.
The 2024 Travel + Leisure Reader Survey: How the Top Islands Are Chosen
Each year, over 186,000 T+L readers cast their votes for the world’s best travel experiences. Islands are rated on natural attractions, activities and sights, restaurants and food, friendliness of the people, and overall value. The final rankings reflect the average scores for each category, based on direct traveler experience.
Galápagos Islands: Ecuador’s Timeless Natural Wonder
Once again, the Galápagos Islands in Ecuador take the No. 1 spot—winning T+L’s “World’s Best” title for the 24th year running and earning a reader score of 91.26. This volcanic archipelago, famous for its role in Charles Darwin’s theories, still captivates with a magical blend of endemic wildlife, untouched beaches, and one-of-a-kind adventures. Visitors rave about seeing giant tortoises, blue-footed boobies, marine iguanas, and over 9,000 species that call these islands and surrounding waters home.
Travelers describe their experiences in the Galápagos as “once-in-a-lifetime.” Many feel deeply moved by the natural wonders on display, and several call the islands “soothing to the soul.” Strict conservation ensures that much of the wild, unspoiled character Darwin encountered in the 19th century remains today, making it a true bucket-list destination for nature lovers.
Caye Caulker and Ambergris Caye: Belize’s Twin Paradises
Just offshore from the Belize Barrier Reef, two islands consistently capture travelers’ hearts—each with its own distinct energy. Caye Caulker, at No. 2 with a score of 87.71, charms with its barefoot, backpacker-friendly atmosphere, vibrant local culture, and relaxed pace. Reviewers praise its small-town feel and affordable eats, calling it “the little sister to Ambergris Caye.”
Ambergris Caye, No. 3 with a score of 84.56, turns up the luxury while keeping its easy Caribbean vibe. With upscale resorts and direct access to world-class diving at the Great Blue Hole, it attracts both adventure-seekers and travelers looking for refined comfort. Both islands offer outstanding snorkeling, warm hospitality, and endless turquoise views, but you’ll find a different rhythm on each.
Isla Mujeres: Mexico’s Laid-Back Gem
Just a short ferry ride from Cancun’s famous Hotel Zone, Isla Mujeres (No. 4, score 82.03) is a complete escape from the mainland buzz. Life slows down here, especially on Playa Norte—consistently rated as one of Mexico’s most beautiful beaches. T+L readers speak of their decades-long love affairs with Isla Mujeres, with many visiting 20 times or more. It’s the kind of place people dream of moving to, thanks to its clear water, friendly locals, and relaxed charm.
Roatán Island: Honduras’ Hidden Jewel
Rounding out the list at No. 5 is Roatán Island, Honduras (score 80.31). Still relatively off the beaten path, Roatán’s pristine beaches, calm waters, and abundant coral reefs are perfect for snorkelers, divers, and anyone looking for tranquility without the crowds. Readers call it a “well-kept secret,” highlighting its authenticity, natural beauty, and fewer tourists compared to other regional hotspots.
The Complete Top 5 Islands in Mexico, Central, and South America for 2024
- Galápagos Islands, Ecuador – WBA Hall of Fame honoree; Reader score: 91.26.
- Caye Caulker, Belize – Reader Score: 87.71.
- Ambergris Caye, Belize – WBA Hall of Fame honoree; Reader Score: 84.56.
- Isla Mujeres, Mexico – Reader Score: 82.03.
- Roatán Island, Honduras – Reader Score: 80.31.
Why These Islands Stand Out
Each island brings something unique to the table. Galápagos is a living museum of evolution and wildlife. Caye Caulker and Ambergris Caye let you choose between backpacker cool and barefoot luxury. Isla Mujeres delivers pure beach bliss within easy reach of Cancun, and Roatán is the quiet paradise you’ll want to keep to yourself. Across the board, T+L readers praise the local hospitality, natural beauty, vibrant activities, and value.
Plan Your Island Escape
Whether you crave wild nature, dive adventures, or the world’s softest sand, these islands promise unforgettable memories and a true sense of escape. In 2024, let the favorites chosen by thousands of travelers inspire your next tropical journey.
